Author Archives: Margit Lehis
ESAF Annual Meeting 2023
11.–12. September, 2023
West University of Timișoara, Romania
See the annual meeting photo gallery here.
PROGRAMME
DAY 1, 11 September
18 | Welcome cocktail |
19 | Dinner. Speakers: – European University Alliances – a new bridge for European identity. Opportunities for science advice (presentation slides). Prof. Irina MACSINGA, Professor of psychology, Dean of the Faculty of Sociology and Psychology, West University of Timișoara – Franklin A. CARRERO-MARTÍNEZ, Senior Director, Global Sustainability and Development & Science and Technology for Sustainability, The National Academy of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine |
DAY 2, 12 September. ESAF Annual Meeting 2023 | |
09:30 | Opening and introductions |
Chair: Prof. Mădălin BUNOIU, West University of Timisoara • Message from Prof. Marilen Gabriel PIRTEA, Rector of West University of Timisoara • Prof. Tudor PRISECARU, Secretary of State in the Ministry of Research • Prof. Tarmo SOOMERE, ESAF Chair, President of Estonian Academy of Sciences • Jaques VERRAES, Deputy Head of Science Policy, Advice, and Ethics Unit, European Commission |
|
10:30 | SESSION 1. MESSAGES FROM ROMANIA AND EUROPEAN COMMISSION |
Chair: Prof. Tarmo SOOMERE, Estonian Academy of Sciences • Research and Science Advice Systems in Romania. Prof. Tudor PRISECARU, Secretary of State in the Ministry of Research • Research Environment in Timișoara (presentation slides). Prof. Florin Alin SAVA, vice-rector for research, West University of Timisoara • The European Science for Policy ecosystem (presentation slides). Alessandro ALLEGRA, Policy Assistant to the Deputy Director-General for Research and Innovation, European Commission • “Towards sustainable food consumption. Promoting healthy, affordable, and sustainable food consumption choices”. GCSA Scientific Opinion published in June 2023 (presentation slides). Jacques VERRAES, Deputy Head of Science Policy, Advice, and Ethics Unit, European Commission |
|
11:30 | Coffee break |
11:45 | SESSION 2. ERA OF TRASH INFORMATION PROVIDED BY ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND CHALLENGES OF SCIENCE ADVICE |
Chair: Prof. Maria Chiara CARROZZA, President of the National Research Council of Italy • Key-note presentation: The emergence of the pseudo-scientific discourse: crisis of science or crisis of the public sphere? (presentation slides). Professor Alina BÂRGĂOANU, PhD. The Dean of the College of Communication and Public Relations, National University of Political Studies and Public Administration, Bucharest, ROMANIA. Member of the advisory board of the European Digital Media Observatory, affiliate member of the European Center of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats, Helsinki. • Challenges to science advice in the context of AI ‘hallucinations’ (presentation slides). Franklin A. CARRERO-MARTÍNEZ, Senior Director, Global Sustainability and Development & Science and Technology for Sustainability, The National Academy of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine • Undermining Trust: The Impact of Scientific Fraud on EU Financing and Research Integrity (presentation slides). Robert MISTRIK, Slovak Research and Development Agency • Ongoing SAM work on Artificial intelligence for research and innovation. European Commission (presentation slides). Jacques VERRAES, Deputy Head of Science Policy, Advice, and Ethics Unit, European Commission • DISCUSSION |
|
13:20 | Lunch |
14:20 | SESSION 3. HOW TO MAKE NATIONAL SCIENCE ADVICE TRANSFERABLE TO OTHER COUNTRIES? |
Chair: Robert MISTRIK, Slovak Research and Development Agency • Warsaw Communiqué on Climate Change in Europe (presentation slides). Prof. Gerald HAUG, President of the German Academy of Science Leopoldina (remotely, represented by Dr. Lucien Brujan) • EU perspectives on evidence-informed policymaking in governance and public administrations (presentation slides). Agnieszka GADZINA-KOLODZIEJSKA, deputy Head of Unit Science for Democracy and Evidence-Informed Policy Making, Joint Research Centre • Speaking truth to power: towards building resilient democratic citizenry in a challenged legally based world order. Prof. Silviu ROGOBETE, PhD. Former Consul General of Romania in South Africa, Director of the Doctoral School of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science at West University of Timișoara • Interventions by ESAF members – recent changes in Science Advice Systems ESAF members • DISCUSSION |
|
16:00 | Convenience Break |
16:10 | SESSION 4. ESAF MEMBERS CLOSED MEETING. DISCUSSIONS ON THE FOUNDING DOCUMENTS AND FUTURE OF ESAF. ELECTION OF THE ESAF NEW CHAIR |
Chair: Prof. Tarmo SOOMERE • Overview of ESAF activities 2022–2023. Prof Tarmo SOOMERE, ESAF Chair • European Commission expectations on how to work together with ESAF. Alessandro ALLEGRA, Policy Assistant to the Deputy Director-General for Research and Innovation, European Commission • New statute of ESAF. Changes in Terms of Reference and membership agreement (presentation slides). Anne-Greet KEIZER and Members of the Working Group • Election of the new chair for the next 3 years. |
|
19:00 | Networking Dinner |
Report: Planetary Health. An emerging field to be developed
The Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW) just published a new report called Planetary Health. An emerging field to be developed.
The press release and a summary or the full report you can read here.
If climate change, biodiversity loss and other environmental changes continue unabated, billions of people will face serious health risks by the end of this century resulting from heat stress, flooding, food shortages, infectious diseases, migration and conflicts. Research examining the connection between such environmental changes and human health (the field of study known as Planetary Health) is still in its infancy. The report reviews existing scientific knowledge in this area and offers a list of questions for researchers to address.
New WRR publication: Mission AI. The New System Technology
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) and the international publisher Springer have published: ‘Mission AI. The New System Technology’. This Open Access book can be downloaded free of charge (as an ebook) or can be ordered as a deluxe hardcover book via the Springer website.
The impact of Artificial intelligence
The WRR states Artificial Intelligence (AI) should be considered a system technology, similar to the steam engine, electricity, the combustion engine and computer. Taking this approach helps to look beyond the issues of the day and instead make long-term recommendations about how AI can be embedded in society. By viewing AI as a system technology, drawing analogies and learning lessons from other similar technologies, it is possible to gain some insight into the impact of AI. At this level, the recommendations are of value to governments in other countries as well.
Springer Book Series: Research for Policy
In this series, we publish internationally relevant studies of the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy. Many of the cross-cutting issues that affect Dutch policymaking, also challenge other Western countries or international bodies. By publishing these studies in this international open access scientific series, we hope that our analyses and insights can contribute to the policy debate in other countries.
More information about the Springer Series can be obtained here.
About the WRR
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) is an independent advisory body for government policy. The task of the WRR is to advise the Dutch government and Parliament on strategic issues that are likely to have important political and societal consequences. More information about the WRR can be obtained here.
Recently published by WRR and Springer: Migration Diversity and Social Cohesion. Reassessing the Dutch Policy Agenda
A new book from the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) and the international publisher Springer: ‘Migration Diversity and Social Cohesion. Reassessing the Dutch Policy Agenda’. This Open Access book can be downloaded free of charge (as an ebook) or can be ordered as a hardcover book via the Springer website.
Strategic direction for migration policy
Policymakers across Western-Europe have grappled with how to respond to the increasing diversity in cities, towns and neighbourhoods, resulting in a plethora of policy initiatives, some more effective than others. This book shows what could work. It brings together a large amount of research and provides evidence-based policy recommendations. For policymakers, this book offers both a sense of strategic direction and more specific, actionable advice. The report is broad in that it covers many different policy areas that touch on issues of diversity, from immigration policy to education and labour policy. It will be of benefit to all those making policy for a country of immigration.
Springer Book Series: Research for Policy
In this series, we publish internationally relevant studies of the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy. Many of the cross-cutting issues that affect Dutch policymaking, also challenge other Western countries or international bodies. By publishing these studies in this international open access scientific series, we hope that our analyses and insights can contribute to the policy debate in other countries.
More information about the Springer Series can be obtained here.
About the WRR
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) is an independent advisory body for government policy. The task of the WRR is to advise the Dutch government and Parliament on strategic issues that are likely to have important political and societal consequences. More information about the WRR can be obtained here.
ESAF Annual Meeting 2022 (ESAF-8) „The role of science advice in rebuilding the society“
Date: 29–30 November (Starting time 14:30, 29 November; ending time 13:30, 30 November)
Venue: Research Council of Lithuania, Gedimino pr. 3, 01103 Vilnius
PROGRAMME
Moderator Prof. Tarmo Soomere, Chair of ESAF, President of Estonian Academy of Sciences
NOVEMBER 29 | |
15:00 | Opening and introductions – Jacques Verraes, European Commission, DG Research & Innovation – Prof. Romas Baronas, Chairman of the Research Council of Lithuania – Prof. Jūras Banys, President of the Lithuanian Academy of Sciences – Facts and figures about the Research Council of Lithuania: interplay of society, scientists, government and politicians (presentation slides). Dr Reda Cimmperman, Scientific Secretary, Research Council of Lithuania |
15:35 | Session 1. The role of science advice in rebuilding the society |
Introduction to the topic. Main activities of the Members and Secretariat of ESAF for ESAF purposes” (file) (Stand 27 Nov 2022) Prof. Tarmo Soomere, Chair of ESAF, President of Estonian Academy of Sciences |
|
Prof. Da-Chuan Cheng, Director of Science and Technology Division, the Taiwanese Representative Office in Lithuania | |
How to advise your government on the challenges of a tilting world order? (presentation slides) Anne-Greet Keizer, Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) |
|
16:35 | Break |
16:50 | Keynote. Additional material “Action Steps for Rebuilding Ukraine’s Science, Research, and Innovation”. Vaughan Turekian, Executive Director Policy and Global Affairs, (remotely); Franklin Carrero-Martinez, Senior Director, Global Sustainability and Development & Science and Technology for Sustainability Policy and Global Affairs, U.S. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine |
17:20 | Independent expert report: Strategic crisis management in the EU Dr. Maarja Kruusmaa, member of the EC Group of Chief Scientific Advisors, member of the Estonian Academy of Sciences, (remotely) |
17:35 | Keynote. Science in Ukraine: survive, transform, take the lead (presentation slides). Dr. Oleksiy Kolezhuk, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, (remotely) |
18:05 | Roundtable discussion: How can ESAF collectively contribute to the rebuilding of societies |
19:00 | Dinner |
NOVEMBER 30 | |
10:00 | Session 2. Recent developments |
Science for policy: developments in Finland (presentation slides) Dr. Jaakko Kuosmanen, Finnish Academy of Sciences |
|
10:40 | Session 3. The mandate and the future of ESAF |
Introduction of European Commission Staff Working Document: Supporting and connecting policymaking in the Member States with scientific research (presentation slides) Kristian Krieger, European Commission, Joint Research Centre; Jacques Verraes, European Commission, DG Research & Innovation |
|
11:35 | Break |
11:50 | Changes in ESAF ToR Prof. Tarmo Soomere, Chair of ESAF, President of Estonian Academy of Sciences |
12:10 | Roundtable discussion |
12:30-15:45 |
Dr. Mădălin Bunoiu, Romanian ESAF Representative, Chairman of the National Council for Research, Development and Innovation. Proposal for 2023 ESAF 9th Annual Meeting, Romania. (proposal slides) |
Gallery – ESAF General Assembly 2021 (ESAF-7) “From local advice to global benefit”
November 29, December 1, 2021. Tallinn, Estonia.
Photos by Aavo Kaine.
ESAF General Assembly 2021 (ESAF-7) “From local advice to global benefit”
ESAF General Assembly 2021 (ESAF-7) “From local advice to global benefit” took place place from November 30 to December 1, at the Estonian Academy of Sciences, Tallinn, Estonia as a hybrid event.
Background: The recent developments and challenges in the science advice ecosystem for policy include inter alia aspects such as (i) success of ad hoc groups, (ii) issues of legislation, mandate, and openness/embargo of provided advice, (iii) bottlenecks of sharing of operational advice between countries, (iv) links to sectorial and EU-level science advice.
It is time to discuss how to bind together country-scale advice with the benefit on regional and continent level. It is natural that governments listen first of all their own scientists, but the knowledge base of these scientists is global. There is no national mathematics or local pandemic. They are global but must be implemented or mitigated in local conditions. It is time to ask questions, such as: Where are the bottlenecks in these aspects? What could we do to reach better performance for everybody? How should we frame the role of ESAF in this context?
- The presentation files and recordins are added to to the programme below.
- Notes (Minutes of ESAF-7, Nov – Dec 2021 in Tallinn) of the meeting.
- Some photos from the meeting can be found in the gallery.
DAY 1, 30 November
14:30–15:00 Arrival, welcome coffee, free discussion
15:00–15:20 Opening and introductions
- Jacques Verraes, Deputy and Acting head of Unit “Science Policy, Advice and Ethics”
- Prof Tarmo Soomere, Chair of ESAF, President of Estonian Academy of Sciences
15:20–17:10 Session 1: Emerging science for policy ecosystem
- 15:20–15:40 Connecting advice on national and EU level. The role of the EC Group of Chief Scientific Advisors. Prof. Nicole Grobert, Chair of GCSA, University of Oxford
- 15:40–16:00 Strengthening the European science advice ecosystem and ESAF’s role in it. Jacques Verraes, Deputy and Acting head of Unit “Science Policy, Advice and Ethics”
- 16:00–16:10 Convenience break
- 16:10–16:50 Mapping and supporting diverse ecosystems within EU Member States. David Mair, Lene Topp, Lorenzo Melchor & Kristian Krieger, Joint Research Centre, European Commission. Presentation file.
- 16:50–17:10 Discussion in break-out groups: ESAF as the connecting link
17:10–17:25 Break
17:25–19:10 Session 2: Lessons and challenges
- 17:25–17:45 Time to take stock: lessons for science advice in future crises. – Prof. Corien Prins. The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy. Presentation file. Presentation video.
- 17:45–18:00 Towards connectivity of national advice systems: experience from ESAF – Prof. Tarmo Soomere, President of the Estonian Academy of Sciences, ESAF Chair
- 18:00–18:20 Creating connections and networks in support of evidence-informed policymaking in Europe – David Mair, Lene Topp, Lorenzo Melchor & Kristian Krieger, Joint Research Centre, European Commission
- 18:20–18:35 International Network for Government Science Advice (INGSA) in European ecosystem of science advice – Kristiann Allen, Executive Secretary, INGSA. Presentation file.
- 18:35–18:55 Discussion in break-out groups: The future of ESAF in the science advice ecosystem.
- 18:55–19:10 Reflections from breakup groups & wrap-up
20:00 Dinner at restaurant “Pegasus” (address: Harju 1, Tallinn) (sorry, only for the participants in Tallinn 🙂 )
DAY 2, 1 December
9:30–10:00 Morning Coffee
10:00–12:30 Session 3: Steps into future
- 10:00–10:20 Experimental development of national science advice: The case of SOFI (Science Advice Initiative of Finland). Jaakko Kuosmanen, Finnish Academy of Science and Letters. Presentation file. Presentation video.
- 10:20–10:40 The potential benefits of Trans-European collaboration in a network of experienced national science advisors within specific knowledge areas. Niels Halberg, Director of Danish Centre for Food and Agriculture. Presentation file.
- 10:40–11:00 Central challenges to evidence informed policy making: The role of values and identities. David Mair & Mario Scharfbillig, Joint Research Centre, European Commission. Presentation file.
- 11:00–11:10 Convenience break
- 11:10–11:30 Scientific advice during Covid-19 pandemic in Estonia: combining local data with global knowledge, Prof. Krista Fischer, COVID-19 science advisory board of Estonia. Presentation file.
- 11:30–11:50 Developing the system of scientific advisers in Estonian ministries. Liina Eek, Estonian Research Council. Presentation file.
- 11:50–12:10 European missions: how to integrate national research and science-based innovation programs to realize the expectations and challenges on the European and National level. Prof. Ričardas Rotomskis, Research Council of Lithuania. Presentation file.
12:10–12:20 AOB and Conclusions
12:20–13:20 Lunch
New WRR publication: Preparing for Digital Disruption
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) and the international publisher Springer have published: ‘Preparing for Digital Disruption’. This Open Access book can be downloaded free of charge (as an ebook) or can be ordered as a deluxe hardcover book via the Springer website.
Digital Disruption
This book offers an analysis of why preparations for digital disruption should become a stated goal of security policy and policies that aim to safeguard the continuity of critical infrastructure. The increasing use of digital technology implies new and significant vulnerabilities for our society. However, it is striking that almost all cyber-security measures taken by governments, international bodies and other major players are aimed at preventing incidents. But there is no such thing as total digital security. Whether inside or outside the digital domain, incidents can and will occur and may lead to disruption. While a raft of provisions, crisis contingency plans and legal regulations are in place to deal with the possibility of incidents in the ‘real world’, no equivalence exists for the digital domain and digital disruption. Hence, this book uniquely discusses several specific policy measures government and businesses should take in order to be better prepared to deal with a digital disruption and prevent further escalation.
Springer Book Series: Research for Policy
In this series, we publish internationally relevant studies of the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy. Many of the cross-cutting issues that affect Dutch policymaking, also challenge other Western countries or international bodies. By publishing these studies in this international open access scientific series, we hope that our analyses and insights can contribute to the policy debate in other countries.
More information about the Springer Series can be obtained here.
About the WRR
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) is an independent advisory body for government policy. The task of the WRR is to advise the Dutch government and Parliament on strategic issues that are likely to have important political and societal consequences. More information about the WRR can be obtained here.
New WRR publication: Acquiring, assessing and weighing. The use of knowledge in policy advice in times of crisis
Essay “Acquiring, assessing and weighing. The use of knowledge in policy advice in times of crisis”.
Preparing for the next crisis means being aware that it will inevitably come. This is the conclusion drawn by the Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR), the Health Council of the Netherlands (GR) and the Council for Public Administration (ROB).
The role of scientific advisors in crisis situations
In crisis situations, scientific advisors play an essential role in the timely acquisition and interpretation of relevant knowledge. It is then the task of politicians and administrators to assess and weigh the knowledge and, on that basis, to decide how to tackle the crisis. The essay highlights three key lessons:
- Adaptivity: crises require politicians, administrators and advisory bodies to demonstrate adaptability. During a crisis, scientific advisors can proactively formulate questions and provide guidance to strike upon answers that will help mitigate the crisis. In addition, they can provide policymakers with greater manoeuvrability by looking further ahead.
- Multidisciplinarity: Advisory boards are composed of different scientific disciplines that can share areas of overlap, but that can also sometimes clash. It is absolutely vital in a crisis in which far-reaching decisions must be made that the full range of perspectives receive due consideration. This requires practice, which can be achieved when advisory bodies endeavour to collaborate more often when crises are not at hand.
- Division of responsibility: tasks and responsibilities are distributed between science, advice and decision-making. Advisory bodies should guard against these responsibilities becoming too intertwined. This becomes particularly vital the longer the crisis persists and the more prominent the role of politics and governance becomes.
The essay is the result of a conference convened by the three bodies to examine the role of knowledge in dealing with an acute, chronic or predicted crisis. During the conference, scientists from a range of disciplines, politicians and administrators discussed these issues.
About the WRR
The Netherlands Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR) is an independent advisory body for government policy. The task of the WRR is to advise the Dutch government and Parliament on strategic issues that are likely to have important political and societal consequences. More information about the WRR can be obtained here.